Super Bowl XLV: Packers and Steelers Battle it Out on Twitter

Who will win Super Bowl XLV, the Green Bay Packers or the Pittsburgh Steelers? Vegas gives the Packers a slight edge but most people think it could go either way.

Last year after winning my Social Media Super Bowl the New Orleans Saints went on to win the actual game. So this year I thought I’d do a similar competition by comparing the official Twitter profiles of both teams.

Will it predict the winner of Super Bowl XLV? Who knows, but I like looking at sports and social media signals and the Super Bowl offers a good analogy for comparing teams.

The figures referenced below are accurate as of February 2, 2011.

Ok, let’s move on to the opening kick-off.

1st Quarter: Most Followers

This is a close one but the Steelers edge out the Packers by roughly 8K followers:

Steelers - Twitter followers

Packers - Twitter followers

It’s worth noting that both teams’ followers are significantly up since the beginning of the season (see: The Most Popular NFL Teams on Twitter and Facebook: 2010 Season). In fact to my knowledge the Steelers didn’t even have an official presence until recently so that shows how quickly they’ve grown their reach.

A TwitterCounter chart for the past three months shows how quickly @Steelers has been gaining followers:

Twitter Counter - Packers vs. Steelers

One negative for both teams: neither is particularly interested in following others. We’ll call that a turnover by both sides.

Advantage: STEELERS

Pittsburgh Steelers helmet

__________________________________

2nd Quarter: Topsy Social Analytics

Topsy recently came out with a new Twitter analytics tool so I thought I’d look at mentions and replies for @Steelers and @Packers in the past month:

Topsy Analytics - Packers vs. Steelers

The level of activity is pretty similar for both teams but that giant peak for the Steelers gives them the edge.

Advantage: STEELERS

Pittsburgh Steelers helmet

At halftime the Steelers are up but it’s a close game. Let’s see what the Packers can do in the second half.

__________________________________

3rd Quarter: Twitalyzer

Which team is making the most impact on Twitter? Twitalyzer gives the Steelers the edge:

Twitalyzer - Pittsburgh Steelers

Twitalyzer - Green Bay Packers

See my post on the Twitter impact of news sites for an overview of how Twitalyzer calculates its Impact scores.

The game remains tight but the Packers can’t seem to close the gap.

Advantage: STEELERS

Pittsburgh Steelers helmet

__________________________________

4th Quarter: Klout

Ok, it comes down to this. Which team is more influential on Twitter? Let’s look at their Klout scores:

Klout score - Pittsburgh Steelers

Klout score - Green Bay Packers

Once again the Steelers beat out the Packers in a close competition.

Advantage: STEELERS

Pittsburgh Steelers helmet

__________________________________

So that’s it. The Packers scored well and the teams were closely matched, but the Steelers win all four quarters to become Super Bowl XLV Champions – at least based on Twitter signals.

WINNER:

Pittsburgh Steelers helmet

PITTSBURGH STEELERS

Now let’s see if the social media winner becomes the real Super Bowl champion for the second year in a row.

Comments

  1. This is fun to read! Enjoy the Super Bowl on Sunday! @katyli

Leave a Comment

*


four + = 12

Thanks for leaving a comment. In the "Name" field above, please use your personal name and not a company name or other phrase.